
Bob Schaffer: The Facts
Bob Schaffer, Jack Abramoff and Forced Abortions on the Mariana Islands
Bob Schaffer visited the Marianas in August 1999 on a
trip he knew was sponsored by Jack Abramoff
- The four-day trip was sponsored by the Traditional Values
Coalition, an organization that figured in the Abramoff scandals when it
was revealed that Abramoff directed one of his clients, gambling firm
eLottery, to pay the organization $25,000.
- In an August 1999 memo, Schaffer
was told that travel arrangements to the Mariana Islands had been made by
Abramoff’s firm, Preston-Gates.
- A year earlier, Abramoff had
sent a memo to a Marianas textile manufacturer Willie Tan detailing a
lobbying plan focused on using congressional oversight hearings to change
the subject from factory conditions to political shenanigans by the
Clinton administration. Trips to the island for congressmen and staff
would be a key tool to “build permanent friends,” the memo said.
Bob Schaffer has taken $9,400 in campaign contributions
from people living in the Northern Mariana Islands
- In 1998, Schaffer received $2000 from Jerry Tan, the vice
president of Tan Holdings Group and CEO of CTSI Logistics. Tan Holdings is
the largest textile manufacture on the island, and Jerry’s brother Willie
Tan is both the president of Tan Holdings and the contact Abramoff dealt
with while they were his clients.
- On July 21, 2004, Schaffer received eight donations
totaling $7,200, including $500 from Jerry Tan and $1000 from Marian
Aldan-Peirce , who is president of DPS Saipan Limited, a large retailer,
and member of the Saipan Chamber of Commerce’s Government Relations
Committee.
- In 2006, Schaffer received another $200 from Marian
Aldan-Pierce.
Although his was a fact-finding
tour, Schaffer had already made up his mind that there was no worker abuse on
the Marianas. Such allegations had already been substantiated by multiple
sources, including the Department of Interior
- In a press release issued before the
trip, Schaffer called the allegations of worker abuse "false rumors
motivated by local politics."
- A 1998 Department of Interior report
had previously found that forced abortions were a relatively common
practice on the Marianas. “Abortion appears to be a common practice as a
means of birth control,” the report found. “One employee was terminated
following her refusal to have the procedure…She was told that she could
have her old job back after she had an abortion.”
After his visit to the
Marianas, Schaffer turned an oversight hearing on the Department of Insular Affairs
into an attack on the agency
- During a September 16, 1999 hearing of
the House Natural Resources Committee, Schaffer accused the department of
paying workers to protest and providing them “signs, cars and other
resources” to protest during Schaffer’s visit. “I will tell you with
absolute certainty, while I was there in (the Mariana Islands) and
interviewed a number of garment workers, I was told on multiple occasions
that individuals received funds - in fact, $1,200 - from federal officials
to attend this rally and go rent cars, fill up the tank, and feed people,”
Schaffer said during the hearing.”
Also after his visit, Schaffer
twice endorsed a local politician with close ties to Abramoff
- In November 1999, Schaffer endorsed
Benigno Fitial in his race for House speaker of the Commonwealth
Legislature. In an advertisement
published in the Saipan Tribune on congressional letterhead
Schaffer praised Fitial's commitment to "an economic agenda of
growth" and instincts "useful in strengthening a positive relationship"
with the U.S. Congress, according to the Denver Post.
- In 2000, with Fitial now House
speaker, the islands’ legislature passed two resolutions calling for the
government to hire a lobbyist, including one in July 2000 that
specifically called for selecting Abramoff’s firm, Preston Gates, and
ended up costing $100,000 a month.
- In 2001, Schaffer
then endorsed Benigno Fitial in his race for island governor.
According to the Denver Post, the endorsement “was part of a
concerted and public campaign by Republicans on the House Committee on
Natural Resources to boost Fitial's public career when he became key to
extending a multimillion-dollar lobbying contract for Abramoff from the
island's government.”
Abramoff and Fitial both
bragged about their successful relationship
- In 2001, Abramoff wrote a memo to the
Marianas governor justifying his fees. According to the Denver Post,
the memo “points to the lavish trips for dozens of lawmakers and family
members to build goodwill. And he says his connections ultimately scuttled
dangerous legislation like the bill proposed by then-Sen. Frank Murkowski,
R-Alaska, which would have toughened the islands' labor and immigration
laws. ‘We then stopped it cold in the House,’ the memo boasts.”
- In October of 2001, while running for
governor, Fitial told an audience that the federal government would
provide the islands with emergency funds needed after economic shock of
9/11. “I talked to my friend Cong. Bob Schaffer over the phone and he
told me that this assistance will be coming very, very soon,” said Fitial.
Michael Riley, “Abramoff Ties Cloud '99 Fact-Finding
Trip,” The Denver Post, April 10, 2008.
(http://www.denverpost.com/news/ci_8872607)
Campaign finance figures are based on Campaign Money
Watch analysis of data obtained from the Center for Responsive Politics, a
non-partisan organization that tracks and codes campaign finance data by
industry and tracks lobbying. Campaign finance data include individual
contributions ($200+) and from Political Action Committees (PACs) to campaign
committees and leadership PACs. Data for the 2008 cycle were downloaded in
March 2008.
Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands (CNMI)
Labor and Human Rights Abuse Status Report, United States Department of
Interior Office of Insular Affairs, January 29, 1998
to February 14, 1998. (http://www.box.net/shared/89k5pr2zho)
|
Video: "Two Wrongs Don't Make a Right"
|